Thank you all for helpful thoughts, ideas and comments!
Darrell and I spent a few hours online yesterday researching, especially the models/brands mentioned here. I had started this thinking I'd get an air fryer/grill (DIL has a Ninja Foodi from CostCo that she loves). But as I looked, I realized I need air fryer/oven combo more. Our grill is just outside the patio door, in a covered corner so it's out of the worst of the weather which lets us (meaning Darrell!) grill year round. I use the toaster oven that this will replace at least 3 or 4 times a week, so baking is a priority. After all that, especially checking size (I have a lot of counter space, but only 16" from counter to bottom of the cupboard), we settled on a Cuisinart Mod# TOA-65. Ordered it from Best Buy so it should be here by the end of the week. Will let you know how it goes!
Cuisinart.jpg